You found a great passive candidate. You had the convo. They’re warm. Interested. Maybe even a little excited.
Now what?
This is the part where too many recruiting teams lose them.
Why the Handoff Phase Kills Great Passive Talent
Recruiters often think the job ends at "great conversation."
But unless the candidate makes it to the hiring manager quickly (and with proper context), they’re stuck in limbo. And passive candidates don’t wait around. They disappear.
The handoff isn't an afterthought. It's a critical conversion step in the pipeline.
If They’re Not in the ATS, They Don’t Exist
Let’s be real: in many orgs, if a candidate isn't in the ATS, they don’t exist.
Hiring managers and HR teams need visibility. Which means you as the recruiter must take initiative:
- Create an ATS profile yourself
- Submit your own screener summary
- Or send a candidate packet manually if needed
If your team requires an ATS profile before moving forward, do the legwork on behalf of the candidate. It’s worth it for the right candidate.
Resetting the Hiring Manager Mindset
Hiring managers are used to active candidates who chase the job.
But passive candidates are different:
- They may not have a resume
- They’re not job-hunting
- They won’t jump through hoops
That means hiring managers need to shift their expectations:
- Evaluate based on your screener summary, not a perfect resume
- Be willing to hop on a call even if the profile is informal
- Understand that these candidates require a lighter, faster touch
📌 If you’re in a tight labor market, you can’t afford to be picky.
If your active pipeline is dry and you're shorthanded, the burden is on the recruiter and hiring manager to reduce friction and grease the funnel. In a “candidate’s market,” you need to earn their interest.
No Resume? No Problem.
Some of the best candidates you’ll find haven’t touched their resume in years. And they’re not about to update it just for you.
That’s fine.
Use your intake notes. Fill out the application for them. Submit a summary directly to the hiring manager.
This keeps the funnel moving without asking for unnecessary friction.
Don’t Let the Process Drag
Passive candidates are like warm leads in sales: they have a half-life.
If your process looks like this:
- Step 1: Recruiter screen
- Step 2: Schedule for hiring manager (in 5+ days)
- Step 3: Wait for formal 20-step ATS profile
- Step 4: 2nd interview, maybe
- Step 5: 3rd interview
...you’re going to lose them.
You need a 7–14 day path from intro to offer. Not 3+ weeks.
Verbal Buy-In Helps
If you can’t issue an official offer yet, a strong verbal signal from the hiring manager can work wonders.
Something like:
"We're excited about you. I want to talk to our HR team to get things moving. You'll hear from us shortly."
That keeps the candidate warm while HR processes catch up.
Hireline Makes It Easy
Hireline helps ensure that warm passive candidates don’t get lost after the handoff:
- We support ATS integrations to make sure passive leads are captured and visible to your hiring team
- We help recruiters move fast — and coach hiring managers on how to convert passive leads before they lose interest
Our platform streamlines outreach, screening, and handoff — so nothing falls through the cracks
---
Next up in The Passive Talent Pipeline Series: What to Expect From Passive Talent (And Why It Beats Traditional Job Board Traffic)